I just can't make up my mind on this one...
I've been watching it (relatively) regularly since about the age of 9 or so. SO, there's that whole childhood angle wrapped up too. But, I took a break from about the ages of 16 until about 30 and it all just feels differently now. Maybe the death of Michael has something to with that, maybe just my own life changing in various ways...
This version of the story gets a lot of flak for not being the Broadway version. I've heard (and own) the Broadway version as well... oranges to nectarines, people. Similar but different. Take it or leave it, the only thing this adaptation needs to stand up to is itself. As a film, I find that it does that rather well, albeit in a slightly off-putting way.
Off-putting, perhaps because it is trying to cram a Broadway show onto a film stage and can't seem to make up its mind from time to time if it wants to be an intimate showpiece or a long-shot spectacle. Or both at once. But, I've felt that way about everything I've seen from Lumet. Specifically, Dog Day Afternoon. Damned good, but I can't tell if it's broad, short or neither when it comes to the scope of it all.The music though is great, Charlie Smalls and Quincy Jones (Quincy was to work later with MJ on Off the Wall, Thriller, Bad, etc.) with the help of Luther Vandross and Ashford & Simpson created some quite memorable tunes to help make a very individual re-telling of an already culturally-imprinted tale.
No small feat, but at the same time, the movie is just not much fun. How can a film with Michael Jackson, Diana Ross and Richard Pryor (not to mention Ted Ross' ridiculously over-the-top Lion) NOT be fun? I don't really know, but the ingredients just don't jell right here. Almost yes.... but for every spot-on moment there is one or two that hits like orange juice on toothpaste. Just wrong on some level.
It isn't laziness or for lack of trying, I don't think. Something was just ...goofy here. Maybe you can get someone who knows what he's talking about to try a critique of it. I'm not that guy.
But, the soundtrack is one of those where "if you like this kind of thing, you're gonna love this" things.
Here it is in 320 kbps with 500px cover art and corrected id3 tags. (link in comments)
Hell, I'm now one of those buccaneer blogs. So be it.


